Bolted or welded: choosing site connections on a steel package
Most Australian steel is shop welded and site bolted, for good reasons. Where a drawing calls for a site weld instead, it changes the access, the inspection and the tolerance — so it belongs on the drawings early.
In this article
The short answer
Most Australian structural steel is welded in the workshop and bolted on site. Bolting needs no power, no weather window and no inspection at height, and bolted holes absorb the small tolerances that every real building has. Site welding buys stiffness and a cleaner line where a bolt group will not fit, but it costs access, qualification, inspection and programme — so it belongs on the drawings, not in a site conversation.
Ask a fabricator how a frame goes together and the answer is almost always the same: weld it in the shop, bolt it on site. That is not laziness. It is the arrangement that puts the difficult work where the conditions are controlled and leaves the site with work that a crew can do quickly, in most weather, at height, without a generator.
It is worth knowing why, because the exceptions are where the money is.
Why bolting is the default
A bolted connection is fast, it is reversible, and it is checkable by eye and by torque rather than by testing. It needs no power on site and no protection from wind or rain. And critically, bolt holes take up tolerance. Every real building is a few millimetres out somewhere, and a bolted connection absorbs that. A welded connection does not — it wants the members where the drawing says they are.
That last point is the one most often missed. Choosing site welding does not just move work from the shop to the site. It pushes accuracy back onto fabrication and setting out, because there is no longer any slack in the joint to absorb a discrepancy.
What the bolt designation on your drawings means
Australian structural bolting is designated by grade and by how the bolt is installed. The three you will see on drawings, designed to AS 4100:
- 8.8/S — snug tightened. The joint is pulled up tight with a spanner. The bolt carries load in shear and bearing. This covers the large majority of ordinary connections.
- 8.8/TB — fully tensioned, bearing type. The bolt is tensioned by a defined procedure, but the joint is still designed to bear on the bolt shank.
- 8.8/TF — fully tensioned, friction type. The clamping force does the work and the joint is designed not to slip. Faying surfaces have to be prepared to suit, which means the paint system at that interface matters.
The difference matters on site. A snug-tightened joint is quick. A fully tensioned joint needs a defined tensioning method, a competent person doing it, and a record that it was done. If your drawings show TF connections and nobody has priced tensioning and inspection, that is a gap.
When site welding earns its place
There are real cases for it:
- Moment connections where a bolted arrangement stiff enough to do the job will not physically fit
- Architectural steel where a visible bolt group would wreck the detail
- Remedial and retrofit work, where you are joining to existing steel that was never drilled for you
- Closing pieces measured on site, where the dimension could not be known in advance
In each of those, welding is the right answer and the cost is worth paying. The mistake is calling for site welding where a bolted connection would have done, because the detailer defaulted to it.
What a site weld costs that the drawing does not show
A weld symbol takes up no more space on a drawing than a bolt group. On site it is a different animal.
It needs access — an elevated work platform or scaffold, positioned and held while the work happens. It needs power. It needs the weather to cooperate, and wind is as much a problem as rain for some processes. The welder has to be qualified for the position and the procedure, which is not the same as being a good welder. Fit-up has to be right before an arc is struck, so a poorly fitting joint becomes a grinding job before it becomes a welding job.
And it needs inspecting where it sits. A shop weld gets inspected at bench height. The same weld six metres up needs the access equipment there a second time, and if the weld category calls for non-destructive testing, a technician too.
What to settle before shop drawings
- Which connections are bolted and which are welded, member by member
- The bolt designation — S, TB or TF — and who inspects tensioning
- The weld category for every site weld, to AS/NZS 1554.1, and what testing follows
- Whether faying surfaces in friction connections are to be masked or left unpainted
- Who provides access for site welding and inspection, and when it is available
How we handle it
We read the connection schedule before we detail, and if a site weld looks like it could be a bolted connection we ask the question rather than pricing it silently. Where site welding is genuinely needed, we price the access and the inspection with it, because a site weld with no way of reaching it is not a completed connection. Our crew fabricates and installs, so the person welding it on site has usually seen it in the workshop first.
Common questions
Is a welded connection stronger than a bolted one?
Not inherently. Both are designed to AS 4100 to carry the actions the engineer has calculated, so a correctly designed bolted connection and a correctly designed welded connection are both adequate. The real difference is behaviour — a welded connection is stiffer and transfers moment more readily, which is why moment connections are often welded. Strength alone is rarely the deciding factor.
What does 8.8/S mean on my structural drawings?
8.8 is the bolt property class, and /S means snug tightened — pulled up tight with a spanner rather than tensioned to a defined load. The alternatives are /TB and /TF, both fully tensioned, with TF designed as a friction connection that must not slip. The designation matters on site because tensioned bolts need a defined installation procedure and a record that it was followed.
Can you weld structural steel at height on site?
Yes, with the right access, qualified welders and a procedure suited to the position. What it needs is planning: an elevated work platform or scaffold, power, a weather window, and the same access made available again for inspection and any non-destructive testing. Site welding is straightforward work made expensive by everything around it, so it belongs in the programme rather than as a surprise.
Do site welds need to be inspected?
Yes, to whatever weld quality category the drawings nominate under AS/NZS 1554.1. GP welds are inspected visually. SP welds attract a higher level of examination and commonly non-destructive testing. The inspection requirement is the same whether the weld is at bench height or six metres up — only the cost of reaching it changes.
Keep reading
More from the workshop
Welding
GP or SP? AS/NZS 1554.1 weld categories in plain English
AS/NZS 1554.1 sets two weld quality categories. Which one applies changes the inspection, the rework risk and the paperwork you get at handover — so it belongs on the drawings.
Installation
The week the steel arrives: what a builder should have ready
Steel erection runs fast when the site is ready for it and stalls expensively when it is not. Here is what has to be in place before the truck turns up.