Tolerances: what “square and plumb” actually means on a steel package
Steel is never perfectly straight, and AS/NZS 5131 says how straight it has to be. Knowing the difference between essential and functional tolerances settles most handover arguments before they start.
In this article
The short answer
AS/NZS 5131 sets the geometric tolerances for fabricated and erected structural steelwork and divides them into essential tolerances, which affect strength and stability, and functional tolerances, which affect fit and appearance. Steel built inside those limits is compliant even when it is not visually perfect. If a following trade needs tighter than the standard allows, that has to be specified and priced before fabrication, not discovered at cladding stage.
“Square and plumb” is what everyone says and nobody defines. It sounds like an absolute. It is not. Structural steelwork is built to a tolerance, that tolerance is written down in AS/NZS 5131, and steel that sits inside it has been built correctly — even if somebody standing at the end of a line can see it.
Most tolerance disputes are not really disputes about workmanship. They are disputes about which standard applies, and they get settled very quickly once someone opens the right one.
Nothing arrives straight to begin with
Deviation accumulates from the mill onward. Rolled sections come with their own permitted variation in depth, flange thickness and straightness. Cutting and drilling add a little. Welding adds more — heat shrinks metal as it cools, and a beam that went into a fabrication jig straight can come out with a bow that has to be pulled back.
Then it is erected onto a slab that was poured to a concrete tolerance, against holding-down bolts set out by a different trade to a different standard, in weather that expands and contracts everything measurable.
A steel frame is the sum of every one of those. The standard exists because you cannot build one without them.
Essential and functional — the distinction that matters
AS/NZS 5131 separates its geometrical tolerances into two kinds, and the distinction is the most useful thing in the whole section.
- Essential tolerances affect the structural resistance and stability of the frame. Out-of-plumb on a column, straightness of a member in compression, the fit of a splice. These are not negotiable, because the engineer's calculations assumed them.
- Functional tolerances affect everything else — how well the cladding sits, whether a handrail reads as a straight line, how big the gap is where two trades meet. They are about the building working and looking right, not about it standing up.
When somebody says steel is “out”, the first question is which of those two they are talking about. An essential tolerance exceedance is a structural matter and goes back to the engineer. A functional one is a fit-out conversation.
Where the arguments actually happen
Almost always at an interface with another trade, because the other trade works to a tighter standard than steel does.
Glazing and facade systems are the usual one. A curtain wall carries very little slack, and it is fixed to steel that is permitted more movement than the glazing is. Lift shafts are another — plumb over the full rise of a shaft is unforgiving, and the lift supplier's tolerance is not the steelwork's tolerance. Precast panels bearing on steel, and anything with a visible reveal line, round out the list.
None of those are solved by building the steel better. They are solved by designing an adjustable connection at the interface, so the following trade can take up the difference. That is a detailing decision, and it needs making before shop drawings.
Holding-down bolts, the classic
Base plate holes are made oversized precisely so they can absorb the difference between where the bolts were supposed to be and where the concreter put them. There is a limit to that, and every erector has turned up to a slab where the limit was passed.
The cheap fix is a survey. Have the bolt group positions checked and issued before the columns leave the workshop. If something has moved, a base plate can be re-drilled at the bench in minutes. The same problem discovered with a crane on hire and a crew standing around is a different sort of morning.
If you need tighter than the standard
You can have it. It just has to be asked for.
- Name the members or interfaces that need a tighter tolerance, and state the value
- Say how it will be measured, and by whom — a tolerance you cannot verify is not a tolerance
- Allow for it in the programme, because tighter work is slower work
- Consider an adjustable connection instead, which is usually cheaper than chasing the tolerance
How we handle it
We fabricate to AS/NZS 5131 unless the drawings nominate something tighter, and if they do we price it as the extra work it is rather than quietly absorbing it. Before columns leave the shop we want the holding-down bolt setout confirmed. And where steel meets glazing, lifts or precast, we raise the interface at shop drawing stage — it is a five minute conversation then and a very expensive one later.
Common questions
What tolerance does structural steelwork actually have to meet?
The geometric tolerances in AS/NZS 5131, which is the Australian and New Zealand standard for fabrication and erection of structural steelwork. It sets separate limits for essential tolerances, which affect structural resistance, and functional tolerances, which affect fit and appearance. If a project needs tighter than the standard, that has to be nominated in the specification, because the standard is what a fabricator prices against by default.
My steel looks out of plumb. Does that mean it is defective?
Not on its own. Every erected frame has some deviation, and the question is whether it exceeds the limit in AS/NZS 5131 for that member and that dimension. Measure it properly against the standard before calling it a defect. If it is inside the permitted tolerance the steel is compliant, and the conversation shifts to how the following trade takes up the difference.
Who is responsible when holding-down bolts are out of position?
It depends on whose tolerance was exceeded. Bolt setout belongs to whoever placed it, usually under the concrete package, and it has its own permitted deviation. Base plate holes are oversized to absorb normal variation. Where the bolts are outside their own tolerance it is a setout issue, not a steel issue — but either way the cheapest resolution is a survey before the columns leave the workshop.
Can a fabricator build tighter than the standard if we ask?
Yes. Tighter work is achievable with more jigging, more checking and sometimes machining rather than cutting. What it is not is free, and it is slower. Nominate the specific members or interfaces that need it, state the value and say how it will be measured, and it can be priced properly instead of becoming an argument at handover.
Keep reading
More from the workshop
Detailing
Shop drawings: what has to be settled before anyone cuts steel
Shop drawings turn an engineer's design into the pieces a workshop actually makes. Four things hold them up every time, and all four are decided before fabrication starts.
Installation
The week the steel arrives: what a builder should have ready
Steel erection runs fast when the site is ready for it and stalls expensively when it is not. Here is what has to be in place before the truck turns up.